Back to MBCA Home Page

MBCA

Massachusetts Baseball
Coaches Association

President's Message,

MBCA Constitution and By-Laws,
and
MBCA Position on Bats and Federation Rules




PRESIDENT’S MESSAGE

 

 

CONSTITUTION AND BY-LAWS

of the

MASSACHUSETTS BASEBALL COACHES ASSOCIATION, INC.

 

 

CONSTITUTION

 

 

Article I.  NAME

 

The name of this organization shall be the Massachusetts Baseball Coaches Association. 

 

Article II.  PURPOSES

 

Section I:  To foster and promote the game of baseball for the youth of Massachusetts. 

 

Section 2:  To provide a recognize body to submit ideas, suggestions and problems pertinent to baseball for consideration and action by the M.I.A.A. 

 

Section 3:  To bring together those who have a common interest in baseball to discuss problems and to provide the best possible conditions for improving the game. 

 

Article III.  Membership

 

Section I:  There shall be three classes of membership – active, allied, honorary. 

 

a)     Active membership shall consist of individuals who are actively coaching baseball from grades seven through twelve in Massachusetts.  New England College coaches are eligible for active membership. 

 

b)     Allied membership shall consist of individuals who are actively coaching baseball in youth leagues and other persons who are interested in baseball.  They may attend meetings but not vote or hold office. 

 

c)      Honorary membership may be conferred upon any individual who has been an officer in the Association and is no longer actively coaching baseball and upon any individual who, because of his valuable contribution to the game of baseball, shall be nominated by the Executive Committee and elected by two-thirds vote of the Association present.  Honorary members may attend meetings but not vote.

 

 

 

Article IV.  OFFICERS

 

Section 1:  The officers of this Association, elected from the active members, shall be a President, a First Vice-President, a Second Vice-President, a Secretary/Treasurer, and an Assistant Secretary. 

 

Section 2:  The term of office for each officer shall be for two years, except that of the Secretary/Treasurer and Assistant Secretary who may serve for an indefinite period of time.

 

Section 3:  The slate of officers shall be presented by the Nominating Committee at the annual meeting. 

 

Section 4:  Election of officers shall take place at the annual meeting, at which time they shall take office. 

 

Section 5:  Vacancies in offices, other than President, shall be filled temporarily by the Executive Committee and approved by the Association at the following meeting. 

 

Section 6:  No member shall be eligible for election to office who has not been a member of the organization for the minimum of one year. 

 

Article V.  EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE

 

Section 1:  There shall be an Executive Committee consisting of the elected officers of the Association, all past Presidents and past officers, At Large Members, and sixteen active members duly recommended and approved by the Executive Committee. 

 

Section 2:  This committee shall formulate policies and plans. 

 

Section 3:  The President of the Association shall serve as chairman of the Executive Committee. 

 

Section 4:  Vacancies occurring among the members of the Executive Committee, shall be filled temporarily by the Executive Committee and approved by the Association at the following meeting. 

 

Section 5:  The term of the sixteen elected members shall be four years.  There will be four from each district:  Western Massachusetts, Central Massachusetts, Eastern Massachusetts North, and Eastern Massachusetts South. 

 

Section 6:  “At Large” Members may be nominated by the President and approved by the Executive Committee.  “At Large” Members have voting rights.

 

 

Article VI:  STANDING COMMITTEES

 

Section 1:  The Standing Committees shall be appointed by the President. 

 

 

Section 2:  Standing Committees shall be as follows:

 

a)     Nominating Committee

b)     Clinic Committee

a)     Membership Committee

b)     Hall of Fame Committee

c)      Hospitality Committee

d)     Publicity Committee

 

Article VII.  MEETINGS

 

Section 1:  The annual meeting shall be held in the winter for the purposes of hearing reports from the Standing Committees, holding election of officers, and to consider any other old or new business.  The winter meeting shall also consist of a coaching clinic and Hall of Fame induction, and an Honors Luncheon.

 

Section 2:  Special meetings may be called by the President, the Executive Committee, or on application of twelve members of the Association. 

 

Section 3:  Fifteen members of the Association, in good standing, shall constitute a quorum for the transaction of business at the annual meeting. 

 

Article VIII:  MEMORIALS

 

Section 1:  The Association shall recognize the passing of any of its members by either a floral tribute, a spiritual remembrance, or donation to a scholarship memorial.  A member of the Hospitality Committee will ordinarily take care of this duty; if, however, any member realizes that the Association has failed to act in a situation of this king, the person may be authorized by the President to provide an appropriate remembrance.  The bill shall be forwarded to the Secretary/Treasurer for reimbursement. 

 

Article IX:  AMENDMENT

 

Section 1:  This constitution may be amended at any business meeting of the association by a two-thirds majority of the present and duly accredited members. 

 

 

BY-LAWS

 

Article I.  MEMBERSHIP

 

Section 1:  With a two-thirds vote of the membership present at a meeting, a member may be suspended for one year for conduct unbecoming to our Association standards. 

 

Article II. DUES

 

Section 1:  The annual dues of active members shall be $20.00.

 

Section 2:  Allied members shall pay a membership fee of $10.00.

 

Section 3:  Honorary members dues shall be waived.

 

Section 4:  Any member who fails to pay his annual dues for the period of one year shall have his name removed from the active file. 

 

Article III.  DUTIES OF OFFICERS

 

Section 1:  The President shall preside at all meetings.  The President shall exercise general supervision over the affairs and activities of the Association and shall serve as a member ex-officio on all standing committees.  The President shall serve as Chairperson of the Executive Committee. 

 

Section 2:  The First Vice President shall assume the duties of the President during the President’s absence.  The First Vice President shall be responsible to assist the Chairperson of the Clinic Committee and to be the coordinator of the North/South, Central/West, and the MA/CT All Star games. 

 

Section 3:  If the First Vice President is absent, the Second Vice President shall assume the duties of the First Vice President.  The Second Vice President will assist the Chairperson of the Hall of Fame Program.

 

Section 4:  The Secretary/Treasurer shall be the custodian of all Association records, conduct correspondence, and perform such other duties as the office may require.  The Secretary/Treasurer shall receive and safeguard all Association funds and shall make an annual report of receipts and disbursements.  Furthermore, the Secretary/Treasurer shall coordinate the duties of the executive cimmittee members responsible for :

 

a)     Clinic program directory

b)     Clinic registration

c)      Membership records

 

Section 5:  The assistant secretary shall be responsible for the recording of the minutes of all executive committee meetings and distributing them for approval at the next executive committee meeting.

 

Article IV.  DUTIES OF EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE

 

Section 1:  The Executive Committee shall have the general direction and control of the affairs of the Association, and shall establish the dues structure for the baseball coaches association. 

 

Section 2:  No matter, not previously acted upon and approved by the Executive Committee, shall be acted upon by the general membership assembled at a regular meeting. 

 

Section 3:  The Executive Committee shall meet at least twice a year, prior to the annual meeting.  At these meetings, the Committee shall approve or disapprove all matters presented by members for consideration.  Special meetings of the Executive Committee may be called by the President or upon written request of five members of this Committee. 

 

Section 4:  The Executive Committee shall recommend to this Association one member of the Executive Board to serve on the Massachusetts State Baseball Tournament Committee sponsored by the M.I.A.A.  The Executive Committee shall present recommendations to be considered by the M.I.A.A. concerning tournament play. 

 

Section 5:  Six members of the Executive Committee shall constitute a quorum. 

 

Article V.  DUTIES OF THE STANDING COMMITTEES

 

Section 1:  The Nominating Committee shall be responsible for recommending the best qualified candidates for Association officers and members of the Executive Committee. 

 

Section 2:  The Clinic Committee shall be responsible for making arrangements and conducting the Winter Clinic.  All Standing Committee Chairpersons shall be included as members of this committee. 

 

Section 3:  The Membership Committee shall be responsible for encouraging members to participate in all Association activities and to orient prospective members to the aims and objectives of the Association, and administer clinic registration. 

 

Section 4:  The Hall of Fame Committee shall be responsible for recommending to the Executive Committee at its fall meeting coaches who have coached high school baseball in Massachusetts, and because of their length of service, devotion to the game of baseball, and contribution to the development of youth, are qualified to become members of the Massachusetts Baseball Coaches Hall of Fame.  Requirements for entry to the Hall of Fame are:

 

a)     Length of service should be a minimum of 15 years of high school baseball coaching. 

 

b)     A nominee who has coached high school baseball 15-20 years must be retired for a minimum of 5 years. 

 

c)      A nominee who has coached high school baseball more than 20 years must be retired for a minimum of 2 years. 

 

d)     A nominee who has coached high school baseball over 25 years is automatically eligible for nomination. 

 

e)     The list of criteria for selection should include:  character, longevity, activity in the Association, and record.

 

Section 5:  The Hospitality Committee shall be responsible for sending a communication to a member relative to illness, condolence, or act deserving of congratulatory recognition. 

 

Section 6:  The Publicity Committee shall be responsible for informing news media of the activities of the Association.  The Publicity Committee shall be responsible for publishing the Massachusetts Baseball Coaches Association Newsletter. 

 

Article VI.  PARLIAMENTARY AUTHORITY

 

Section 1:  Robert’s Rules of Order, Revised, shall be the parliamentary authority for this organization on all matters not covered by the Constitution and By-Laws of this organization. 

 

Article VII.  AMENDMENT

 

Section 1:  Any amendment to these By-Laws may be proposed at any regular meeting, to be adopted at the following meeting by a majority vote of the present and duly accredited members. 

 

Article VIII.  ORDER OF BUSINESS

 

Section 1:  The order of business at all meetings of this Association shall be as follows:

 

a)     Meeting called to order

b)     Secretary’s roll call

c)      Formal introduction of any new members

d)     Secretary’s report

e)     Treasurer’s report

f)        Communications

g)     Reports of Standing Committee

h)      Unfinished business

i)        New business

j)        Adjournment

 

 

 

Article IX.  CONSTITUTION AND BY-LAWS REVIEW

 

Section 1:  A committee shall be established to review the constitution and by-laws every three years.  All Executive Board members shall receive an updated copy of the constitution and by-laws at the beginning of each new business year. 

 

Revised:

 

3/96

3/99

10/02

10/04

10/06

Next revision 10/09


 

MBCA Executive Board - Position on Bat of Choice
 

Massachusetts Baseball Coaches:  This is the official position paper of the Massachusetts Baseball Coaches Association Executive Board. We sent this letter to the MIAA Board of Directors as well as to the MIAA Baseball Bat Task Force. Our position was presented at the MIAA meeting on January 15 and was instrumental, we believe, in convincing the Task Force to continue to allow choice of metal or wood bats for the 2003 regular season.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
   The Massachusetts Baseball Coaches Executive Board would like to express its position on the current bat issue. We strongly favor continuing the current MIAA bat regulations, which allow metal bats to be used during the regular season. We are extremely disappointed by the October 31 vote by the MIAA Baseball Committee to ban metal bats for MIAA tournament play in 2003, especially in light of the fact that the MIAA Sports Medicine Committee had previously voted against its own proposal to ban metal. We urge the Task Force to support the Sports Medicine Committee on this issue.

   It appears that the decision by the Baseball Committee is based primarily, if not solely, on safety concerns, yet there is no statistical evidence that metal bats are less safe than wood. Those who have studied this issue concur. Mr. Todd Stevenson, Secretary of the U.S. Product Safety Commission stated on April 5, 2002 “available incident data are not sufficient to indicate that non-wood bats may pose an unreasonable risk of injury.” Dr. Frederick Mueller, who is Director of the National Center for Catastrophic Sports Injury at the University of North Carolina, collects injury data for the NCAA and National Federation of State High School Associations (NFHS). Dr. Mueller stated in a letter to the MIAA on November 8, 2002, “I am not aware of any data that suggests there is a rise of injuries to baseball players from batted balls hit by non-wood bats.” He cites data compiled from 1982-2001 by the National Center, which show an occurrence of less than one batted ball injury for every 100,000 pitchers. The Medical/Safety Advisory Committee of USA Baseball gathered data from 1989-2001 on catastrophic injuries (fatalities, disability injuries, serious injuries with recovery) in baseball. Their final report shows a rate of 0.11 injuries per 100,000 participants, another indication that baseball is a very safe sport. NCAA statistics show that baseball continues to rank among the safest sports, both in frequency and severity of injury. Finally, Massachusetts head coaches, in a recent survey, reported a total of 14 batted ball injuries in 22,400 games, or about one injury per 1600 games. The NFHS, NCAA, U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission, Little League Baseball, PONY Baseball, Babe Ruth Baseball, and USA Baseball have all studied, and not prohibited, metal bats.

   The fact is that metal bats have changed in the last few years to perform more like wood. In 2001, the NCAA, NFHS, and MIAA enforced two new bat rules. First, a bat must have a “minus 3” differential between its length and weight (for example, a 33 inch bat cannot weigh less than 30 ounces). Previously, “-5” was the standard. Second, the maximum allowable barrel diameter was reduced from 2 ¾ to 2 5/8 inches. Another regulation, created by the NFHS and adopted by the MIAA, becomes effective January 1, 2003. This states that all non-wood bats must have the Ball Exit Speed Ratio (BESR) certification mark to be legal for high school baseball. The BESR limitation is intended to have the ball exit metal bats at speeds no greater than those off wood. The NFHS states that, “All recent changes in bat requirements have been to minimize the risk of injury to high school student-athletes, and maintain the balance between offense and defense and keep within the sound traditions of the game.” We have not played even one season in Massachusetts with these new regulations in effect.

   A study done by Mr. Joseph J. Crisco at Brown University, has been cited by some who favor wood bats, yet Mr. Crisco’s study actually shows that legal metal bats perform similar to wood. Mr. Crisco tested five metal bats and one wood bat and his report shows that 4 of the 5 metal bats tested “outperformed” the wood bat. However none of those four metal bats are legal, according to current MIAA standards, as they are all “-5” or “-4” bats. The only “-3” bat in the study, according to Mr. Crisco, “was not statistically different from bat W [wood bat]” and “one metal bat [the –3 bat] was more similar to wood.”

   We believe the game of baseball in Massachusetts is currently in excellent condition and is not in need of the proposed change in bat regulation. The data presented show there is no crisis at hand and emergency rule changes are not warranted. We coaches, who have dedicated our careers to coaching high school baseball, have always been interested in a game that is safe, fair, promotes sportsmanship, and is enjoyable for players, parents, fans, and coaches. Our current game provides just that. We ask you to please consider all this information when making your decision, one that we hope results in the continuation of metal bats as an option for league and tournament play. Thank you very much.
 

Respectfully Submitted,

Massachusetts Baseball Coaches Association Executive Board
Bat Subcommittee Members:

Bob Ashley   Frank Carey      Dan Dulchinos
Stoughton High School North Reading High School    Chicopee Comprehensive HS
 

Paul Fenton   Peter Pasquarosa     Pete Moscariello
Auburn High School  Franklin High School     Reading High School
 
 
 
 
 

Dear MIAA Baseball Committee;

The Massachusetts Baseball Coaches Association (MBCA) continues to be adamant in its support of allowing member schools to have their choice of using wood or BESR certified non-wood bats for tournament play as well as in the regular season.

Mr. Frank Carey, baseball coach at North Reading High School and the MBCA’s representative to the MIAA Baseball Committee, will make an official proposal at the October 22 Baseball Committee meeting that both wood bats and BESR certified non-wood bats be allowed in the MIAA Baseball Tournament. Approval of this proposal would mean that tournament games are played with the same set of rules as regular season games (where both non-wood and wood bats are allowed). Approval of this proposal would be consistent with recent decisions by other MIAA committees and would put an end to this year-long controversy.

The following is an outline of what has transpired in the last year regarding the bat issue:

? Last fall, the MIAA Sports Medicine Committee voted 15-0 against a proposal to prohibit non-wood bats (October 2002).

? The MIAA Baseball Committee voted, on October 31, 2002, to make wood bats mandatory for the 2003 MIAA Baseball Tournament.

Since that October 31 meeting much has transpired, all of which indicates that coaches, Athletic Directors, Principals, and MIAA Committees all desire to allow BESR certified non-wood bats to be allowed in Massachusetts.

? In December, the MIAA Board of Directors created a Baseball Bat Task Force who studied the matter in great depth, receiving both written and oral expert testimony on both sides of the issue, particularly around the issue of safety. The Task Force concluded, by a 7-1 vote (Jan. 2003), that there was “no compelling evidence that metal bats were significantly more dangerous than wood.”

? At the MBCA annual meeting (Feb. 2003), 72% of Massachusetts baseball coaches voted to support the continued use of non-wood bats for regular season and tournament play.

? The Massachusetts Secondary Schools Athletic Directors Association voted 14-2 to reject the proposal to ban non-wood bats.

? At the MIAA’s Annual Meeting last spring voted, 68% of Mass. Principals and Athletic Directors voted against the proposed ban on non-wood bats (vote was 78-37).

? The MIAA Board of Directors voted (May 2003) by a 10-6 count to reject the proposal to prohibit non-wood bats.

? The Massachusetts Interscholastic Athletic Council (MIAC), the ultimate rule-making committee of the MIAA, voted 12-5 against a proposal to ban non-wood bats from high school play (May 22, 2003). Therefore, in 2004 and 2005 member schools/leagues will have their choice of bats, metal or wood, during the regular season.
 

? This past June, after the 2003 baseball season and tournament, Mass. baseball coaches received a survey from the MBCA with two clearly posed questions and responded as follows: 74% said they agree with the ruling that allows schools to use bat of choice while 67% disagreed with the MIAA dictating that wood bats must be used in the tournament.

? Mr. Paul Wetzel, MIAA Spokesman, stated in this fall’s issue of Coaching Management magazine “I can’t speak for the [baseball] committee members, but there’s a sense that having been turned down for a regular season change, they will go back to allowing non-wood bats for the 2004 tournament. It doesn’t make sense to keep one set of rules for the regular season and another for the playoffs.”

With the safety issue having been thoroughly investigated, discussed, and resolved by the committees and groups mentioned above, this matter should now be a non-issue. Rule changes should be implemented only when there is clear, conclusive evidence that such changes are necessary to improve a sport, not merely on the personal preference of a handful of individuals. No factual evidence or logical reasoning warranting a rule change has been presented by wood bat proponents during this year-long debate. The MIAC, the MIAA Board of Directors, the MIAA Sports Medicine Committee, Mass. Athletic Directors, Mass. principals, and Mass. coaches have all agreed on this:  we simply want the rules that had been in place for the past 30 years, that allow member schools to have the choice of non-wood or wood bats, to be reinstated.

We ask the MIAA Baseball Committee to support the proposal to allow BESR certified non-wood bats for regular season and tournament play.
 

Respectully Submitted,
Mass. Baseball Coaches Association Executive Board
 
 
 
 
 

Massachusetts Baseball Coaches Association
 

MBCA Survey Results

• Mass. Baseball Coaches Association Executive Board voted, 17-1, in favor of allowing metal bats for regular season play

January 2003 survey of Mass. Head Baseball Coaches:
• 72% coaches prefer to use metal bats
• 66% coaches have seen zero batted ball injuries in their careers (0 injuries in 895 total years)
• 91% coaches have seen 3 or less injuries (40 injuries in 1330 years = 1 injury per 33.3 years)
• Overall average of 1 injury per 12.5 years = 1 injury per 793 days of games/practices
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Safety: Injury Data

• Todd Stevenson, Secretary for U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission (April 2002), “available incident data are not sufficient to indicate that non-wood bats may pose an unreasonable risk of injury.”

• Dr. Frederick O. Mueller, Director of the National Center for Catastrophic Sports Injury (November 2002), “I am not aware of any data that suggests there is a rise of injuries to baseball players from batted balls hit by non-wood bats.”

• Medical/Safety Advisory Committee of USA Baseball report shows overall injury rate of 1.1 “catastrophic injuries” per one million participants

• Little League Baseball study (1997-2001):   1.1 batted ball injury per 10,000 players

• NCAA statistics:  less than 1 batted ball injury per 10,000 players

• Baseball is very safe sport: has lower injury rate than boys soccer, girls soccer, boys basketball, girls basketball, softball, wrestling, and football.

• Metal bats have been studied and not prohibited, by:  National Federation of State High School Associations (NFHS), NCAA Blue Ribbon Research Panel, U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission, Little League Baseball, PONY Baseball, Babe Ruth Baseball, USA Baseball
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Safety: New Bat Regulations for 2003

Effective January 1, 2003: all metal bats must have Ball Exit Speed Ratio (BESR) certification, ensuring:
• a maximum exit speed which limits performance to mirror wood bats
• adherence to Moment of Inertia requirement
• barrel diameter not exceeding 2 5/8 inches
• length to weight differential of no greater than minus-3

• NFHS News Release (March 2002): “All recent changes in bat requirements have been to minimize the risk of injury to high school student-athletes, and maintain the balance between offense and defense and keep within the sound traditions of the game.”

• Report by Joseph J. Crisco reveals that the only minus-3 metal bat (M1) tested “was not statistically different from bat W [wood bat]”. Also states, “one metal bat [M1] was more similar to wood.”
 
 
 

VICTORY, 2002 !!!

The MIAA has voted not to pursue the adoption of Federation Rules for baseball in Massachusetts at the high school level.  For all practical purposes, this issue is not going to be considered for a long time as I quote Bill Gaines of the MIAA, "not in my lifetime."  This decision was in part due to the strong stance that the MBCA took on this issue as we followed its progression through the many committees of the MIAA.

The information on Federation Rules will be left on this web site for all coaches to read and be aware of not only the stance the MBCA took on this position in 2002 but also the reasoning behind that stance.
 
 

MBCA Executive Board - Position on Federation Rules Adoption

The following has been accepted, by unanimous vote, as the official position of the Massachusetts Baseball Coaches Executive Board regarding National High School Federation Rules for Baseball.

The Massachusetts Baseball Coaches Association’s Executive Board is unanimously opposed to adoption of Federation Rules. We believe that high school baseball in Massachusetts is in excellent shape, any way one measures it. Our current rules, which combine the Official Rules of Major League Baseball with many MIAA and league amendments, provide for safety, participation, sportsmanship, and an exciting, classic brand of baseball. Our current rules are serving well our players, coaches, umpires, and school officials. Thus, we see no need for the significant rule changes presented by Federation Rules.

We are not simply opposed to change; in fact we have willingly accepted many rule changes in the past few years. As a result, our current rules already include nearly all of the safety, sportsmanship, and participation-enhancing rules that appear in the Federation Rules (such as the sliding rules, no-collision rules, new bat regulations, re-entry rules, and DH for any player). Thus, the real differences in the two sets of rules are in the way the game of baseball is actually played.

We have studied Federation Rules thoroughly and we see no advantage for players, coaches, or umpires. Rather, we believe that Massachusetts’ players have an advantage (over players from other states) as they join college programs, where the NCAA rules are very close to Official Rules and differ greatly from the Federation’s.

We have spoken with numerous coaches from neighboring states, every one of whom has told us that Federation Rules have had a negative impact on playing and officiating the game without offering any benefits. Furthermore, these coaches expressed displeasure that Federation Rules are in constant change, with three to five rule amendments each year. This makes both knowledge and proper enforcement of the rules increasingly more difficult. In Massachusetts, we are certain that play under Federation Rules would cause countless conflicts, misinterpretations, and protests; a potential nightmare for players, coaches, umpires, Athletic Directors, and other officials.

The following are just a few examples of the numerous significant rule differences between our current rules and Federation Rules. There are certainly many more; in fact the book entitled Baseball RuleDifferences by Carl Childress contains 86 pages and over 400 rule differences. Again note that the typical rule differences are not safety-related, but rather are seemingly nonsensical rules that in no way improve the game.  Some examples are:

Mercy rule – would reduce participation
Intentional Base on Balls – artificial; much can happen on thrown pitches (examples –  Johnny Bench in World Series)
Fake Tag – will lead to misinterpretation and unwarranted penalty
Defensive Conferences – controversial, misunderstood, inconsistent
Offensive Conferences – will slow game
Set Position – position of hands (such pitchers as  Maddux, Clemens, Glavine, Orlando Hernandez would never throw a legal pitch from set according to Federation Rules)
Turning shoulders before set – balk
Batter must keep one foot in box between pitches: penalty is a strike
No appeal plays
NFHS authenticating mark is required on all baseballs
 

On the MBCA Executive Board alone, we have hundreds and hundreds of years of coaching commitment to student-athletes in Massachusetts. We have endured significant changes over the years in rules, equipment, and length of season, as well as a two-year umpire strike, none of which we favored or chose. Yet our game continues to prosper due to the dedication and flexibility of so many coaches. But, Federation Rules go beyond changes that are easily applied and enforced; they pose fundamental and long-lasting changes that are sure to have a negative impact on how baseball is played and enjoyed.

We hope the MIAA respects and accepts the opinions of the coaches, the true experts in the game of high school baseball, and trusts that we are acting in the best interests of our players and schools. We thank the MIAA for its consideration and hope that our statement is influential in maintaining our current rules and the quality of Massachusetts high school baseball.
 
 

Differences between Official Rules of Baseball and Federation Rules

The MIAA is considering adoption of the National Federation of State High School Rules for Baseball for the Massachusetts high school baseball. There are a great number* of differences between the Federation Rules and  the rules we currently use, the Official Rules of Major League Baseball. The following is just a partial list of the rules differences that would make a significant impact on Massachusetts high school baseball.

*To understand just how different Federation rules are from the Official Rules, the book “Baseball Rule Differences” by Carl Childress details 480 rule differences.
 

Page - Rule Number -  Category -  Summary of Rule

7     1-1-5     Positions and Equipment of Players . . . It is mandatory for on-deck batters, batters, runners, retired runners, players/students in the coaches boxes as well as non-adult bat/ball shaggers to wear a batting helmet that meets the NOCSAE standard. The batting helmet shall have extended ear flaps that cover both ears and temples and also display the NOCSAE stamp and the exterior warning statement. . . . When an umpire observes anyone who is required to wear a bating helmet deliberately remove his bating helmet while in live-ball territory and the ball is alive (non-adult ball/bat shaggers required to wear batting helmet in live-ball are even if ball is dead), the umpire shall issue a warning to the coach of the involved team, unless the ball becomes dead without being touched by a fielder or, after being touched, goes directly to dead-ball area. A subsequent violation of the rule shall result in ejection.

14     2-4-3     Intentional Base on Balls     An intentional base on balls may be given by the defensive team by having its catcher or coach request the umpire to award the batter first base. (No pitch needs to be thrown)

19     2-22-2

19     3-3-1a     Fake Tag     A fake tag is an act by a defensive player without the ball that simulates a tag. A fake tag is considered obstruction. PENALTY: The umpire will determine which base or bases shall be awarded, as with any obstruction. The umpire shall also issue a warning to the coach of the team involved and the next offender on that team shall be ejected.

26     3-1-3     Substituting     Any of the starting players may be withdrawn and re-entered once, including a player who was the designated hitter, provided such player occupies the same batting position whenever he is in the lineup. The pitcher is governed by the provisions of Article 2. A substitute who is withdrawn may not re-enter. (This could mean that re-entry rules apply for all games, including MIAA tournament play)

29     3-4-1     Charged Conferences     Each team, when on defense, may be granted not more than three charged conferences during a seven-inning game, without penalty, to permit coaches or their non-playing representatives to confer with a defensive player or players….Prior to accumulating three charged conferences in seven innings or less, a conference is not charged if the pitcher is removed as pitcher.
PENALTY: After three charged conferences in a seven-inning game, or for any charged conference in excess of one in each extra inning, the pitcher shall be removed as pitcher for the duration of the game. (This means that a coach is entitled to three charged conferences without having to remove his pitcher. But, after the third charged conference during regulation play, the pitcher must be replaced as pitcher for the remainder of the game each time the coach confers with defensive player(s). In any extra inning, on the second and each subsequent charged conference, the pitcher must be replaced for the remainder of the game. This means that, in certain situations, a coach can make three “trips” to the mound for the same pitcher in the same inning, yet the pitcher does not have to be removed. In other situations, because of previously accumulated conferences, a pitcher must be removed even though it may be the first trip while that particular pitcher is on the mound)

29     3-4-2     Charged Conferences     Each team, when on offense, may be granted not more than one charged conference per inning to permit the coach or any of that team’s personnel to confer with base runners, the batter, the on-deck batter or other offensive team personnel. The umpire shall deny any subsequent offensive team requests for charged conferences.

31     4-2-2     Ending a Regulation Game . . . The game shall end when the visiting team is behind 10 or more runs after four and one-half innings, or after the fifth inning, if either team is 10 runs behind and both teams have had an equal number of times at bat. (This would make a “mercy rule” mandatory for all games)

37     6-1-1     Pitching     Turning the shoulders to check runners while in contact with the pitcher’s plate is a balk (This applies even if the pitcher has not yet come to his “set” position)

37     6-1-3     Pitching     For the set position… [the pitcher] shall come to a complete and discernible stop (a change of direction is not considered an acceptable stop) with the ball in both hands in front of the body and the entire glove below the chin….PENALTY: The ball is dead immediately when an illegal pitch occurs. If there is no runner , a ball shall be awarded the batter. If there is a runner, such illegal act is a balk. In both situations, the umpire signals dead ball.

38     6-1-6     Pitching     Each state association shall have a pitching restriction to afford pitchers a reasonable rest period between pitching appearances. (Such restrictions may include: a limit on the number of innings a pitcher could throw in a week; and a mandatory rest period between appearances, depending upon the number of innings pitched)

39     6-2-2     Infractions by Pitcher     Illegal acts include:  c.  failing to pitch or make or attempt a play, including a legal feint, within 20 seconds after he has received the ball. PENALTY: The batter shall be awarded one ball. (In the Official Rules, the 20 second rule applies only with the bases empty).

40     6-2-5     Infractions by Pitcher     It is also a balk if a runner or runners are on base and the pitcher . . .places his feet on or astride the pitcher’s plate, or positions himself within approximately five feet of the pitcher’s plate without having the ball. (In the Official Rules the pitcher cannot be on or astride the rubber; there is no “within … five feet” provision)

42     7-3-1     Batting Infractions – A Batter Shall Not: Delay the game by failing to take his position promptly in the batter’s box within 20 seconds. The batter must keep at least one foot in the batter’s box throughout the time at bat. EXCEPTIONS: A batter may leave the batter’s box when:  a.  the batter swings at a pitch;  b.  the batter is forced out of the box by the pitch;  c.  the batter attempts a “drag bunt”;  d.  the pitcher or catcher feints or attempts a play at any base;  e.  the pitcher leaves the dirt area of the pitcher’s mound or takes a position more than five feet from the pitcher’s plate after receiving the ball;  f.  a member of either team requests and is granted “Time”;  g.  the catcher leaves the catcher’s box to adjust his equipment or give defensive signals;  h.  the catcher does not catch the pitched ball. PENALTY: For failure of the batter to be ready within 20 seconds after the ball has been returned to the pitcher, the umpire shall call a strike. If the batter leaves the batter’s box, delays the game, and none of the exceptions apply, the plate umpire shall charge a strike to the batter. The pitcher need not pitch, and the ball remains alive.

45     8-2     Touching Occupying and Returning to a Base     PENALTY (Art. 1-5): For failure to touch base (advancing or returning), or failure to tag up as soon as the ball is touched on a caught fly ball, the runner is out. This is a delayed penalty if not played upon by the defense during same playing action (live ball). After all playing action has ended, the umpire will indicate time-out to call runners(s) out. (In other words, if a runner misses a base or fails to tag up, there is no appeal by the defensive team. If the umpire sees the infraction, he calls the runner out. Also, say a runner misses a base or leaves too soon and, during live action, proceeds to a succeeding base: if the ball becomes dead, the runner is not permitted to return to that missed base and would be called out).

51     8-4-2g     A Runner is Out g. . . . If, in the judgment of the umpire, a runner, including the batter-runner interferes in any way and prevents a double play anywhere, two shall be declared out (the runner who interfered and the other runner involved). If a retired runner interferes, and in the judgment of the umpire, another runner could have been put out, the umpire shall declare that runner out. If the umpire is uncertain who would have been played on, the runner closest to home shall be called out. (The difference here is that in Federation Rules, except for an illegal slide on a force play, the umpire must believe that the defense could have completed the double play if not for the interference in order to call two outs; if a double play was considered not possible, only one out may be called, even if the interference was deliberate. In the Official Rules, with a double play possible, two are out if the interference is obvious and deliberate, whether or not the umpire judges the double play could have been completed).

12     1-3-4     Equipment     The Coefficient of Restitution (COR) of baseballs shall not exceed .555

12     1-3-4     Equipment     The NFHS authenticating mark is required on all balls that will be used in high school competition.

12     1-3-5     Equipment . . . Devices designed to remain part of the bat, such as batting donuts and wind-resistant devices, are legal. NOTE 2: The NFHS Baseball Rules Committee and Board of Directors are considering a new bat rule. Please refer to www.nfhs.org for current information. The new bat rule appears to be the same one that the MIAA has adopted: 2 5/8 diameter barrel, -3 weight-length.

19     2-22-1     Obstruction     When obstruction occurs, the ball becomes dead at the end of playing action (always a delayed dead ball) and the umpire has authority to determine which base or bases shall be awarded according to the rule violated (the ball becomes dead only “after runners have gone as far as possible”, which may allow the defense to record outs).

21     2-28-3     Pitcher, Pitch, Pivot Foot     Time of pitch is when the pitcher has committed himself to delivering the pitch to the batter. Following part of rule was new for 2000:  For the windup position, the “time of the pitch” occurs when the pitcher, (a) with both hands in front of his body first starts any movement of his arm(s) or leg(s) prior to delivering the pitch; (b) with both hands at his side, first starts any movement with both arms or leg(s), prior to the pitch; (c) with the glove hand in front of the body and the pitching hand at his side, after bringing his pitching hand to his glove hand, first starts any movement of his arm(s) or leg(s) prior to delivering the pitch.

22     2-32-1

22    2-32-2     Slide Appears to be compatible with MIAA Slide Rule: A legal slide can be either feet first or head first. If a runner slides feet first, at least one leg and buttock shall be on the ground. If a runner slides, he must slide within reach of the base with either a hand or a foot.
A slide is illegal if: . . . f.  the runner, on a force play, does not slide on the ground and in a direct line between the two bases. EXCEPTION: A runner may slide or run in a direction away from the fielder to avoid making contact or altering the play of the fielder.

27     3-3-1c, f    Bench and Field Conduct     A coach, player, substitute, attendant or other bench personnel shall not:  c.  wear jewelry (players participating in game);  f.  wear bandannas

31     4-2-3     Ending  a Regulation Game . . . If the game is called when the teams have not had an equal number of completed terms at bat, the score shall be the same as it was at the end of the last completed inning; except that if the home team in its half of the incomplete inning, scores a run (or runs) which equals or exceeds the opponent’s score, the final score shall be recorded as when the game is called. This differs from the Official Rules of Major League Baseball:  rule4.12 (a) (5)

31     4-2-4     Ending a Regulation Game     A state association may adopt game-ending procedures that determine how games are ended, including suspended games. However, if a state does not adopt game-ending procedures, by mutual agreement of the opposing coaches and the umpire-in-chief, any remaining play may be shortened or the game terminated. NOTE: If a state association has adopted game-ending procedures, only those game-ending procedures may be used, should the opposing coaches wish to terminate a game.

32     4-4-1f     Forfeited Game     A game shall be forfeited to the offended team by the umpire when a team: f.  is unable to provide at least nine players to start the game or cannot provided eight players to finish the game. NOTE 1: An out will be called each time that spot in the batting order comes to bat. If the offensive player must be substituted for after reaching base, the most recent batter not on base is allowed to run for that player.

32     4-5     Protested Game     It is optional on the part of a state association as to whether protests are permitted. When allowed, protests are permitted regarding rules one through nine only….

33     5-1-1h     Dead Ball     Ball becomes dead immediately when:  h.  the umpire handles a live ball or calls “Time” for inspecting the ball or for any other reason, including items in Section 2 or gives the “Do Not Pitch Signal”.

33     5-1-1k     Dead Ball     Ball becomes dead immediately when:  k.  a balk or illegal pitch is committed.

37     6-1-2     Pitching     New NFHS rule in 2000: For the windup position, the pitcher is not restricted as to how he shall hold the ball. A pitcher may assume the windup position when his hands are (a) together in front of the body; (b) apart (both arms at the pitcher’s side and then he goes directly into his delivery to the plate); (c) apart and he then brings his hands together and comes to a stop to adjust his grip or the ball before beginning his delivery.

43     7-4-1a     Batter Is Out     A batter is also out as in above penalty when:  a.  the batter enters the batter’s box with an illegal bat or is discovered having used an illegal bat. If the infraction is discovered before the next pitch following the turn at bat of the player who used an illegal bat, the defense may take the penalty or the result of the play.

45     8-2-5     Touching, Occupying and  Returning to a Base     If a runner who misses any base, including home plate desires to return to touch the base, he must do so immediately. If the ball becomes dead and the runner is on or beyond a succeeding base, he cannot return to the missed base and, therefore, is declared out.

48     8-3-3d     Baserunning Awards     Each runner is awarded:  d.  one base . . . with less than two outs, the batter hits a fair or foul ball (fly or line drive) which is caught by a fielder, who then leaves the field of play by stepping with both feet or by falling into a bench, dugout, stand, bleacher or over any boundary or barrier such as a fence, rope, chalk line or pre-game determined imaginary line. NOTE: A runner shall not be declared out if the fielder deliberately throws or carries the ball into dead ball territory to prevent that runner who has touched or advanced beyond a succeeding base from returning to a missed base or a base left too soon. Award the runner two bases.

50     8-4-2b, c,d,e,f     A Runner is Out     This is different from the Official Rules of Major League Baseball, but appears to be same as MIAA rules:  Any runner is out when he:  b.  does not legally slide and causes illegal contact and/or illegally alters the actions of a fielder in the immediate act of making a play, or on a force play, does not slide in a direct line between the bases. NOTE: Runners are never required to slide, but if a runner elects to slide, the slide must be legal. (See complete rule on pages 50-51)

61      Suggested Speed-Up Rules By state association adoption any, all, or any part of the suggested speed-up rules may be used. Rules include courtesy runners for pitchers and catchers; see complete list on page 61.